| 20/20 Heavy This
is a trike for my brother who is about 6'4" and around the 250lb mark (so
far ;)). He was very athletic through his youth and has strong legs and
he always made my other trike frames look like wet noodles when he was cranking
along, so I changed the design a little to try to make a frame that can take what
his legs are putting out. I
made a little calculator that does some basic engineering calculations and by
switching from 1" x .049" square steel tubing to 1¼" x .049"
square steel, the strength goes up about 60% and the weight actually goes down
by about 5%. It should be strong enough, doesn't look too "bulky"
(at least to my eyes) and the walls should be thick enough to prevent oil-canning,
so I think/hope it'll be a success. As a sort of surprise for him, his wife
is helping build it. So far, there's no part on it that she hasn't fabricated
- I'm just welding the pieces together :) He rarely checks the site out,
so I think I'm pretty safe posting the progress :)
| The initial
3D model looks like this. The steering details aren't included because I
know what their design is and I know they already work. This was modelled
before I changed the boom design too. The 3D modelling is mainly to confirm/set
up the frame in relation to the wheel sizes, the track and to make sure the frame
is long enough for the intented X-seam. The frame sections sticking out
behind the rear wheel are for a trailer hitch, but I left it off the trike because
I didn't want to add another 12" or so of length when I'm trying to make
the boom fold. I'll put lots of tabs on the rear end of the real trike and
see what I can come up with for a hitch mount. |  | | | |
| Sept 7 2006 So
far, the frame looks like this. It's the same twin rail style I've been
building, but it uses the beefier 1¼" tube instead of the normal 1"
I use. The dimensions were modified slightly to use a 20" rear wheel
instead of a 24" or 26" rear wheel that I normally use. I also
used a 14mm, 48 spoke rear wheel so that all three wheels would match. This
meant that on the freewheel side, I had to grind down the bearing cone and the
jam nut a little so they would fit down inside the freewheel body without hitting
it. I also used 3/16" thick steel for the dropouts instead of the normal
1/8" because the 14mm axle slot was so big compared to a normal 3/8"
axle. The seat frame is the standard
design I've used for a while now using 1" EMT. I'll likely switch to
plain 1" steel tubing with .064" wall as it means I won't need to remove
galvanized coatings anymore. The seat rails have about 9" of adjustment
fore and aft with ¾" hole spacing. To try to make my trikes
a little more compact, I decided to try something a little different with the
boom. Another home
builder took my frame design and used a bike
rear end bolted to the front of the crossmember instead of making a boom like
mine. I liked it because it looked like the boom would fold back, so I made
a similar style for this one using ½" x .064" box steel. The
two upper boom arms are bolted to tabs on the front of the cross member and the
single lower boom arm will be fastened at the bottom between two tabs using a
Q/R skewer. When required, remove the skewer, and the boom/BB will pivot
up, back and down onto the seat to reduce the overall length by almost 18".
It'll be reinforced a little more than it is at this stage, so I think it'll
be strong enough. With the boom folded and the wheels popped off (a 60 second
job), the trike should be small enough to fit in the trunk of a car. I'll
have definite measurements once the boom and seat are done. The
rear derailleur tab, seat brackets, brake mounts and rear tabs are fabricated,
they just need to be welded on and a little profiling on the welding beads. Then
the steering can be finished and the chainline run. Hopefully most of it
will be done by the end of the weekend. | | | | |
| 26 Sept
2006 Slowly making headway. Chain
was run, pulleys and lower chain tube installed, cable guides and stops for the
rear derailleur were welded on and the handle bars installed. To the right
is a close-up of the boom hinges. The black quick release at the bottom
is removed to allow the boom to swing up and have the chain rings sit in the seat.
The chain goes slack, but I'm not going to worry about some kind of take-up
rig for the chain because it would need to be folded fairly often to make the
weight and complexity worth the while. Folding
the boom back really shortens the trike by taking 13" off the length and
by removing the trike's wheels, it takes another 21" off the length for a
final number of 41" long. That's short enough to fit in the trunk of
a car with 21" wide by 41" long by 20" high. Also, so far,
the boom has no problem with bounce or yaw, but I'll see how it reacts to twisting
from pedalling. If it turns out to be too light, I can always replace it
with a ¾" box tube version and it'll still fit the same hinge points.
My daughter and I stood on the frame rails to "test" it, and with
a combined weight around the 350lb mark (I'm about 210lbs of that . . . :)) it
held us with no problem and there was no rail flexing, so I'm pretty happy about
that. I wouldn't dare such a thing with the 1" box tube. Next,
weld the front derailleur post, a couple more cable stops, a flag tube and two
or three more tabs, mock it up for a test ride, and she's ready to go to powder
coating. | | | | |
| 30 Sept
2006 Well, I've been slowly plugging
away at it each night, save for 1, and it's pretty much done. I got it all
mocked-up last night for its first test drive but I only used my aluminum mock-up
bushings instead of the real Delrin ones. The reason for that is I found
that pressing the bushings in and out during various stages in the building process
invariably loosens them up a little in the king-pin housings and causes a little
slop when the trike is finished. To avoid that, I made up some aluminum
copies that have a 1" x 1/8" flange with a ¾" OD body and
a ½" hole drilled up the middle. I also made them about 2"
long and slightly under 3/4" OD so they go in and out of the king pin housings
by hand but are tight enough to give fairly accurate and tight pivots so I can
set up the direct steering and proper tie-rod length. Anyway,
I took the trike for a little ride and it rolled really well, and had no nasty
noises or bad habits/idiosynchrasies. I think I've mentioned it before,
but I always look forward to the first official test drive so I can see what kind
of personality each new bent has. The trike has very nimble steering, a
seemingly very tight turning radius and pedals very easy even though I only had
about 30 psi in the 65 psi tires. There was no boom bounce, no boom yaw,
no pedal steer and only slight boom roll when I was pushing a big gear. Boom
weakness was a big worry for me due to the different design and lighter construction.
It shifted easily and crisply front and rear, and I managed to get the seat angle
set so that it is comfortably laid back and only about ½" in front
of the rear tire. Too many times, I built the trike to the length that I
thought it needed to be with a laid back seat (45º or lower) only to find
that once the seat was where I wanted it, I had lots of room between the seat
back and the rear wheel. This trike has no wasted space like that but unfortunately,
it still ended up weighing in at about the same as the other trikes I've made
:) I guess the 42 lb range is pretty much the limit for the type of steel
I use. Part of the issue, I think, is the 48 spoke BMX rear wheel, and the
thick and fat Kenda tires. The wheel is pretty heavy compared to the lighter
26" wheels I've used in the past, but at the very least, it is much stronger
than my other trikes but no heavier. I also tried folding the boom and found
that there were no cable or chain snags, and that the folding action didn't instigate
any unintended gear changes at the front. The only drawback is that the
chain goes a little slack as you can see in the picture. Can't win 'em all
:) Folding the boom back into place was equally easy and the chain dropped
right into the guide pulley groove on it's own, the chain placement on the chainwheel
was bang on, and you could immediately ride it away. While
I have the flag tube, a small bracket to support the lower chain tube and the
bidon mount to install yet, they're all cut out and ready but since the trike
is fully assembled I thought I'd take the opportunity to get the child seat mounts
squared away. With all the parts present, I wanted to make sure there were
no interference issues before I painted or powder coated any pieces. The
child seat was the same one I used with my little guy on the Battleship
and as he's riding a little trike and a two-wheeler now, I'm making the seat so
it can mount on the trike for my brother's little girl. The front adapter
is made out of dual ½" box tube and attached down on the seat mount
flanges that are welded to the frame. The flanges I added at the back of
the chain stays have the rear seat mount adapters bolted to them. By removing
1 quick release and two wing-nut bolts, the child seat and the adapters lift right
off in under 1 minute. I have a carbon fiber fender that a friend of mine
(Larry ) made for me, so I'll use it for a rear fender and extra protection for
the baby to keep her feet away from both the spokes and the tire. Tomorrow
I weld the last three pieces on first thing, and then I'll use some 1" x
3/16" AL flat stock to make the fender mounting brackets and the fender guard.
After that, I'll do a quick wire wheel pass on the frame to prep it for
powder coating on Monday. | | | | |
| 5 Oct 2006 The
trike went out to powder coating Tuesday morning, it was done and picked up before
supper, and it was assembled by 10 PM. As a painter, I really love powder coating.
There's no way, with my resources and budget, that I could hit the frame
with a durable and tough top-coat and have it dry and assembled the same day. Anyway,
the bare frame as pictured is everything required except for the bike parts. It
weighs 23 lbs. Heavy I guess, but for an inexpensive steel frame, once assembled,
the trike really moves along nicely. | |
| The
trike is fully assembled with basic bike parts - nothing fancy or expensive. Basic
14mm BMX wheels front and rear, 8 speed freewheel, basic twist shifters and derailleurs,
threadless BB and $15 48/38/28 steel 152mm cranks, and some strong BMX side pull
calipers and levers. The only really expensive components are the platform/SPD
Wellgo pedals. It was slightly overcast and gloomy so the flash on the camera
made the blue tires look a little weird. Even though there's a bit of tread
on the Kenda tires and they're only rated at 65 psi, the trike rolls very well
and is fast and stable. With some Schwalbe Stelvios or Marathons, it'll
really fly. You might be wondering
what's up with the funky rear fender. Well, I added extra tabs to the rear
end to be able to mount a childs' bike seat, and the funky holed panels in the
fender mounts also act as foot guards, as does the fender. The carbon fibre
fender is the same style as used on my Speed
and was built by Larry.
The fender is very strong and very stiff and matches the trike very well,
I think. To make sure the fender minimized spray coming up off the rear
tire, I added a piece of anti-freeze jug, that I sprayed flat black, to act as
a flexible mud flap. The fender supports are hardware store variety 1"
x 1/8" AL, formed around an old piece of swing set leg, and drilled with
3/8" holes to lighten them slightly and spruce them up a bit, and the drilled
side panels were made out of a few scrap pieces of .032" 2024 with ¾"
holes drilled in them and rivetted to the fender supports.. | |
| | | So
my new neice can enjoy the trike too, until she's old enough to ride her own or
ride in a trailer, I refinished the child seat frame and mounted it up. The
close up shows the two 3/8" bolts and wing nuts for the rear mounts, and
the quick release for the front support is down just behind the seat support mount
on the frame. Overall, I'm very happy with
the trike. The frame feels much more stiff than the 1" frame, it feels
nice and tight, tracks straight and true and the chain line runs very smooth.
My brother also said he really liked it once he finally came back from the
test ride and caught his breath :) The only unknown is how the boom will
react to long term pedalling stresses. If it does fail or get twisted badly,
I'll just remake it out of ¾" box and then it'll be bulletproof, and
the extra weight will be negligible. Only
things to add for later are things like a speedo, rear view mirror, lights, a
flag and maybe some front fenders. | | | | |
| 20 Oct 2006 The
trike handled very well at the velodrome
races and was actually faster and easier to control than my Catrike Speed.
Due to the slightly wider frame, the seat mesh was a little too wide and
didn't tighten the way I'd like, so I made a new yellow mesh that was slightly
narrower, and it now tightens correctly. Also, I put 3 new Schwalbe Stelvios
on it and it is even faster and smoother than with the Kendas due to the very
smooth tread pattern on the Stelvios. The thing I was concerned about was
whether the 30mm rims would be too wide for the narrow Stelvios, but they fit
fine. There is also tons of side clearance with the rear tire now, so the
rear fender can go back on with no fear of rubbing on hard corners. Last
thing to do is mod the rear rack, and it's done. | |
| | | |
20 Dec 2006 I
wasn't entirely happy with the original boom I made out of ½" box.
It had more twist than I liked so I made another one out of two ¾"
box sections on top to replace the original ½" ones. I left
the bottom piece at ½" and thought I'd see if it was stiff enough.
If it was, it would be a little lighter than the ¾" version,
and if it was still too weak, I could always build a third with all three tubes
being ¾". The top one compares
the old on the right and the new on the left. The bottom picture has the
new boom on the trike. The upside is that it was also a prime opportunity
to try out the new boom jig. So the
new boom is on, and the trike is done excpet for modifying a bike rack once commuting
weather hits. | |
| | | |
07 Feb 2007 The
plan was to take the trike down to the Brantford
ice races, so we needed to make some skate blade adapters, and a dual brake
assembly that could quickly bolt to the rear end to provide rear wheel braking.
The blade adapters were made from 1" box tube and some ½"
box tube, and the rear brake mount was made out of ½" box steel. Both
assemblies simply bolt on after the rear fender is removed and the front wheels
and brake calipers were taken off. The
new boom worked great, so there's no need to use ¾" square tube on
all three boom tubes. The traction was great, but I totally missed the boat
with the blades. The blade pivot was mounted too far to the rear, and I
think the blades might be too short as well. The result was it was a bear
to steer smoothly, it chattered on the turns, and too much weight was on too small
a blade area, so it wasn't fast. The brakes worked well enough though. So,
as the Toronto ice races are coming up, I'm making some new blades that will mount
further to the rear and properly (I hope) distribute the weight, and then we'll
see how it runs. | | | | | 10
Feb 2007 I kept the old blade adapters,
but just changed out the blades and made new ones out of 1/8" mild steel
instead. I offset the mounting holes this time so the weight sits more in the
middle of the blade and it steers much better. It's smoother, and a little
faster, but in the end, its forte is tires and the street. It'll still be
fine for lower speeds and maneuvering or endurance events like the slalom or lap
races, but high speed cornering on ice sets up too much vibration and chattering
from the high lateral forces. It's
been converte back to tires and hopefully nature will cooperate and let us get
back to riding early this year. | | | 26
June 2007 In preparation for the Ride
for Heart '07 in Toronto, I wanted to put a rack and bags on the trike. Both
had been in my garage since building the trike but time and necessity were not
big motivating factors until the ride approached. We were doing 75km and
I wanted to make sure tools, some food, drinks, some place to carry clothing,
etc was taken care of prior to the ride because I didn't want to have to lug all
that in my tailbox. :) The rack was
from Canadian Tire and had an aluminum deck with steel legs rivetted on. The
steel legs were the bonus because all I had to do was use a piece of angle iron
for the front mounting tab and then set the angle for the rack's deck. After
that, I measured how long the steel legs were, cut out the excess and weld them
back together, shoot the paint, and bolt them on. The rack is essentially
mounted to the fender and fender stays because the combination of the 4 aluminum
fenders stays plus the CF fender is more than strong enough to support the front
end of the rack while the two steel legs support the rear. A little flat
black paint and she's good to go. | |
The specs are the following:
| | | | Length: | 73" 60"
41"
| | Height: | 26" |
| Width: | 31" |
| Track: | 26" |
| Wheelbase: | 41" |
| Seat height: | 8½" |
| BB height: | 17" |
| Ground clearance: | 3" |
| Turning circle: | 11' |
| Caster: | 16º |
| Seat angle: | 45º (adjusts
from about 40º to 65º) | | Weight: | 43
lbs (45 lbs as ice racer) | | Front wheel: | 20"
BMX, 48 spoke w/14mm axle | | Rear wheel: | 20"
BMX, 48 spoke w/14mm axle, and 7 spd | | Gear
inches: | 20" - 87.27" (48/38/28 and
28 - 11) | | Weight bias: | 61f/39r |
Main |